Home security cameras are everywhere now. Nearly every block has at least a few doorbells or cameras recording 24/7. This technology has completely changed how dog bite cases get proven or contested in Tennessee courts.
When video evidence works in your favor
Camera footage can be the strongest evidence in your case. Here’s what it can prove:
- The attack actually happened: No more arguments about whether the incident occurred or how severe it was
- The dog wasn’t restrained: Shows the animal was loose, off-leash, or broke through inadequate fencing
- You didn’t provoke the dog: Contradicts owner accusations that you teased, hit or antagonized their pet
- The owner knew about the problem: Prior footage showing earlier aggressive behavior proves dangerous propensities
- You had permission to be there: Disproves trespassing defenses when you were making a delivery or visiting
Unlike witness statements that fade or change over time, video doesn’t forget details or get nervous on the stand.
When cameras complicate things
While video doorbells and security footage can be quite valuable, it could also create problems you didn’t expect.
Neighbors might not want to share their recordings. Getting footage from unwilling third parties can require subpoenas and legal action. Many camera systems automatically erase old recordings after 30 or 60 days, so evidence disappears if you wait too long.
Dog owners control their own cameras. They can delete footage before anyone asks for it. By the time you request the recording, it may already be gone. Tennessee law can penalize destruction of evidence, but usually only after the owner has been put on notice to preserve it.
It is also possible that the footage doesn’t show what you expected. Camera angles can be misleading. Or the video might actually show you ignored a “Beware of Dog” sign or opened a gate you shouldn’t have touched.
Act fast to preserve evidence
If a dog attacks you at or around someone’s home, accessing camera footage right away can be vital. Ask the owner, nearby neighbors and any businesses with cameras pointed toward the area. Don’t wait weeks to start gathering evidence.
Security cameras have made some dog bite cases much easier to win. They’ve also created new ways for cases to fall apart. The difference could come down to who secures the footage first and what that footage actually shows.